THE WRITING
Tim Cook and John Ternus Can Both Be Right About Touchscreen Macs
Though I still have no use for them, personally
Loading public activity…
"Huh?"
Okay so we all know about Steve's rant back in 2010 about touchscreen laptops and how it's a terrible experience because you're constantly raising and lowering your arm and it gets tiring and uncomfortable.
On the other hand, we've got John Ternus in The Year of Our Lord 2026 releasing a Mac with exactly that. As we all know, this clip has shown up in every single review or discussion about the laptop.
Here's the Thing
I agree with Steve—I don't have much use for a touchscreen laptop and I've never missed it on a MacBook Pro. I think it's a bad experience and I don't like using them really ever. I've got a ThinkPad with a touchscreen for work and I can count on one finger the number of times I've wanted to touch the display.
Does That Actually Matter?
But: for some people, they don't really care. People aren't trying to go around touching the screen the whole time, but for some people, touching/pointing to the thing that they're talking about or looking at is the most natural thing for them. They don't care about getting the fingerprints on the screen, they're just using the computer the way they think it should work.
Considering Interaction Design
In the design of technology, we have to consider how people are naturally using devices. As touchscreens have become more prevalent, people expect screens to be touch sensitive. People don't really want to spend their days holding their arm up and navigating the UI. They probably don't even really want to do it all that often. But that doesn't matter. If they touch the screen expecting something to happen, then something should happen.
This is a pretty basic principle of design; if it looks like it does something, then it should do something. It doesn't matter if it's the best way to do things, it doesn't matter if the screen gets all smudge-y, and it doesn't matter if the thought of a touchscreen Mac makes my skin crawl.
It may be a bad experience to constantly be holding up your arm, which is not something people are trying to do with a touchscreen. It's a worse experience to try and do something normally and it not working. If you tap on the screen, something should happen. It's that simple.